Keeping the faith: The university experience and apostasy
Paul Grayson J.
2020
Canadian Journal of Higher Education
1
In 1963, Glendon College, York University, located in Toronto Canada, admitted mainly Christian students of European origin to a small liberal arts program. Fifty years later the College remained small with a continuing, but less embracive, commitment to the liberal arts; however, the student body included large numbers of young adults who professed religions other than Christianity and came from backgrounds other than European. Within this context, this article focuses on the impact of the Glendon College experience on students’ religious identification and participation in religious services. Overall, I find that in the mid-sixties the College experience contributed to changes in the religious identification of students. By contrast, a half-century later, students’ post-secondary experiences were of little consequence for religiosity. One possible explanation for differences in the College effect is that because of the current racial and religious diversity of Toronto, students are more likely than in the past to confront their religious identities in high school. © 2020, Canadian Society for Studies in Higher Education. All rights reserved.
Change; Liberal arts; Religiosity; University experience
Ontario Catholic secondary curriculum policy document for religious education, grades 9–12, (2016); Bell D., Bell’s bullpen, hypocrisy, ProTem, 5, (1963); Bibby R. W., Religious polarization in Canada: A major empirical update [Paper pre-sentation], (2015); Brown L., Ontario Catholic schools quietly admitting students of all faiths, (2014); Calhoun C., Explanation in historical sociology: Narrative, general theory, and historical specific theory, American Journal of Sociology, 104, 3, pp. 846-871, (1998); Caplivitz D., Sherrow F., The religious drop-outs: Apostasy among college graduates, (1977); 2011 national household survey: Immigration, citizen-ship, place of birth, ethnicity, visible minori-ties, religion and Aboriginal peoples, (2013); Cote J., Identify formation, youth, and develop-ment, (2016); Population: Ethnic groups by age groups, (1961); Population: Religious denominations by age groups, (1961); Eisgruber C., Zeisberg M., Religious freedom in Canada and the United States, International Journal of Constitutional Law, 4, 2, pp. 244-268, (2006); Fosnacht K., Sarraf S., Howe E., Peck L. K., How important are high response rates for college surveys?, The Review of Higher Education, 40, 2, pp. 245-265, (2017); Gauvreau M., The Catholic origins of Quebec’s quiet revolution, 1931-1970, (2005); Message from the principal, (2017); Grayson J. P., Remember now thy creator in the days of thy youth: The quiet religious revolution on a Canadian campus in the 1960s, Historical Studies in Education, 23, 2, pp. 87-112, (2011); Grayson J. P., The experiences and expectations of Canadian female university students in the “Dawn of the Age of Aquarius, Journal of the History of Childhood and Youth, 7, 2, pp. 267-294, (2014); Grayson J. P., The “feminine mystique” and problems of a cohort of female Canadian university students in the early 1960s, The Sixties: A Journal of History, Politics and Culture, 8, 1, pp. 50-74, (2015); Grayson J. P., The ‘first generation’ in historical perspective: Canadian students in the 1960s, Journal of Historical Sociology, 31, pp. 512-525, (2018); Grayson J. P., The life and death of a good idea: Murry Ross’s vision for the “new university, Journal of Canadian Studies, 52, 3, pp. 624-649, (2018); Grayson J. P., Plus ça change…”: Graduates’ views of Canadian females’ opportunities after 50 years of change, Canadian Review of Sociology, 56, pp. 49-77, (2019); Guest M., Aune K., Sharma S., Warner R., Christianity and the university experience: Understanding student faith, (2013); Hiemstra R., Stiller K., Religious affiliation and attendance in Canada, Trust Magazine, (2016); Hill J., Higher education as moral community: Institutional influences on religious participation in college, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 48, 3, pp. 515-534, (2009); Horn M., York University: The way must be tried, (2009); Hunsberger B., Brown L. B., Religious social-ization: Apostasy and the impact of family back-ground, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 23, 3, pp. 239-251, (1984); Hunter J. D., American evangelicalism: Con-servative religion and the quandary of modernity, (1983); Hurtado S., Sax L. J., Saenz V., Harper C. E., Os-eguera L., Curley J., Lopez L., Wold D. S., Arellano L., Findings from the 2005 admin-istration of Your First College Year (YFCY): National aggregates, (2007); Lachmann R., What is historical sociology?, (2013); Lee J. J., Matzkin A., Arthur S., Understanding students’ religious and spiritual pursuits: A case study at New York university, (2004); Lipset S. M., Continental divide: The values and institutions of the United States and Canada, (1990); Lipset S. M., American exceptionalism, (1996); Mahoney J., Revisiting general theory in historical sociology, Social Forces, 83, 2, pp. 459-489, (2004); Maryl D., Uecker J. E., Higher education and religious liberalization among young adults, Social Forces, 90, 1, pp. 181-208, (2011); The Ontario curriculum crades 11 and 12: Course descriptions and prereq-uisites, (2000); Minn J., Silverstein M., Gruenewald T. L., In-tergenerational similarity of religiosity over the family life course, Research on Aging, 40, 6, pp. 580-596, (2018); Moulin D., Negotiating and con-structing religious identities [Paper presentation], 2013 REA Annual Meeting, (2013); NSSE 2018 overview, (2018); Policy statement on religious accommodations in schools, (2017); Canada’s chang-ing religious landscape, (2013); Religious landscape study, (2018); Platt J., Some issues in comparative, macro and international work in the history of sociology, The American Sociologist, 38, 4, pp. 352-363, (2007); Porter J., The vertical mosaic, (1965); Ramsay T., Letter from the editor, ProTem, (2013); Roberts L. W., Clifton R. A., Ferguson B., Kampen K., Langlois S., Recent social trends in Cana-da, 1960-2000, (2005); Ross M. G., The new university, (1961); Schmalzbauer J., Campus ministry: A statistical portrait, (2007); Schwadel P., Birth cohort changes in the association between college education and religious non-affiliation, Social Forces, 93, 2, pp. 719-746, (2014); Stryker R., Beyond history versus theory, Socio-logical Methods and Research, 24, 30, pp. 304-352, (1996); Thiessen J., The meaning of Sunday, (2015); Uecker J., Vaaler M. L., Regnerus M. D., Losing my religion: The social sources of religious decline in early adulthood, Social Forces, 85, 4, pp. 1667-1692, (2007); Van Arragon L., We educate, they indoctri-nate”: Religion and the politics of togetherness in Onatrio public education, (2015); Willits F. K., Crider D. M., Church attendance and traditional religious beliefs in adolescence and young adulthood, Review of Religious Research, 31, 1, pp. 68-81, (1989)
Canadian Society for Studies in Higher Education
Article
Scopus