Liberal education and the possibility of valuational progress
Callard A.
2017
Social Philosophy and Policy
8
10.1017/S0265052517000188
This essay discusses two ways in which an agent can make progress with respect to value: self-cultivation and aspiration. The self-cultivator becomes a more coherent version of the person she was before, acquiring beliefs or desires or habits or skills that serve her antecedent valuational condition. The aspirant, by contrast, acquires new values. The existence of aspiration is under pressure from those who would assimilate it either to self-cultivation, or to a change in value that is done to a person rather than a change that is her own work. I show that those two options cannot be exhaustive by discussing liberal arts education; it is, I argue, paradigmatically aspirational. © 2017 Social Philosophy & Policy Foundation.
Aspiration; College; Education; Rational; Reasons; University; Value
Kolodny N., Love as valuing a relationship, Philosophical Review, 112, 2, pp. 135-189, (2003); Scheffler S., Valuing, His Equality and Tradition, pp. 15-40, (2010); Jay Wallace R., The View from Here, pp. 23-32, (2013); Callard, Aspiration, pp. 4-5; Raz J., When we are ourselves: The active and the passive, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 71, (1997); Ullmann-Margalit E., Big decisions: Opting, converting, drifting, Political Philosophy, 58, pp. 157-172, (2006); Ullmann-Margalit, Big Decisions; Paul L.A., What you can't expect when you're expecting, Res Philosophica, 92, 2, (2015); Callard, Aspiration, pp. V-VI; Brighouse H., On Education, pp. 42-43, (2006); Gordon V.N., The Undecided College Student: An Academic and Career Advising Challenge, (1995); Bartlett Giamatti A., The earthly use of a liberal education, His a Free and Ordered Space: The Real World of the University, pp. 118-126, (1990); Giamatti, Earthly use of a Liberal Education, pp. 118-119; David Velleman J., The possibility of practical reason, Ethics, 106, 4, pp. 694-726, (1996)
Cambridge University Press
Article
Scopus