Modern and pure: Teaching geometry in early twentieth-century women’s colleges
Lorenat J.
2017
Association for Women in Mathematics Series
0
10.1007/978-3-319-66694-5_17
In 1913 The American Mathematical Monthly published an article encouraging the inclusion of synthetic projective geometry in the undergraduate curriculum. The author, William Henry Bussey, lamented that American colleges and universities rarely taught the subject despite its potential for industry, teachers, and the liberal arts curriculum. The following year Lao G. Simons responded in “hearty sympathy” describing the potential of synthetic geometry in broadening “the minds of prospective high school teachers.” Both Simons and Bussey particularly remarked on the success of the course at women’s colleges. Simons herself taught at the Normal College of the City of New York and referred to the appreciation “the girls” had of the subject. Bussey observed that “Bryn Mawr, Mount Holyoke, Smith, Vassar, Wellesley, Wells, and Goucher College of Baltimore” regularly featured the course. Drawing on college catalogs, faculty publications, department histories, course notes, and textbooks, this paper will examine the diverse reasons for teaching this modern pure geometry at women’s colleges in the decade following 1913. © 2017, The Author(s) and the Association for Women in Mathematics.
Mathematics education; Projective geometry; Women’s colleges
Clara Latimer B., The Cartesian Oval and the Elliptic Functions ? and ?, The American Journal of Mathematics, 35, 3, pp. 261-280, (1913); Bourbaki N., Éléments d’histoire Des mathématiques, (1960); Burrell E.L., Course 6. in the Department of Pure Mathematics, (1937); Bussey W.H., Synthetic Projective Geometry as an Undergraduate Study, The American Mathematical Monthly, 20, 9, pp. 272-278, (1913); Cairns W.D., The Sixth Summer Meeting of the Association, The American Mathematical Monthly, 28, 10, pp. 251-363, (1921); Harriet Redfield C., Six Hundred Miles up the Yang-Tse the Smith Alumnae Quarterly, 13, pp. 167-168, (1922); Julian Lowell C., The Rise and Fall of Projective Geometry, The American Mathematical Monthly, 41, 4, pp. 217-228, (1914); Julian Lowell C., A History of Geometrical Methods, (1940); Elizabeth Buchanan C., Review: L. Heffter und C. Koehler, Lehrbuch der analytischen Geometrie Erster Band: Geometrie in den Grundgebilden erster Stufe und in der Ebene, Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society, 13, 5, pp. 247-249, (1907); Elizabeth Buchanan C., Plane Curves of The Eighth Order. Lancaster: The New Era Printing Company, (1908); Elizabeth Buchanan C., Some Suggestions on the Technique of Teaching Plane Geometry, The Mathematics Teacher, 20, 7, pp. 370-374, (1927); Elizabeth Buchanan C., Plane Geometry, (1932); Elizabeth Buchanan C., Solid Geometry, (1934); Cremona L., Elements of Projective Geometry, (1885); Wayland L., Projective Geometry, (1917); Arnold E., An Introduction to Projective Geometry and Its Applications, (1905); Judy G., Laduke J., Pioneering Women in American Mathematics: The Pre-1940 PhD’s, (2009); Lehmer D.N., An Elementary Course in Synthetic Projective Geometry, (1917); Ling G.H., Wentworth G., Smith D.E., Elements of Projective Geometry, (1922); Martin E., Relating to Required Mathematics for Women Students, The American Mathematical Monthly, 24, 8, pp. 394-398, (1917); Merrill H.A., Why Students Fail in Mathematics the Mathematics Teacher, 11, 2, pp. 45-56, (1918); Merrill H.A., Report of the Department of Mathematics for 1917–1918, (1918); Report of the Committee of Ten on Secondary School Studies; with the Reports of the Conferences Arranged by the Committee, (1894); Jean Victor P., Philosophie mathématique. Réflexions sur l’usage de l’analise algébrique dans la géométrie; suivies de la solution de quelques problèmes dépendant de la géométrie de la règle, Annales De mathématiques Pures Et appliquées, 8, pp. 141-155, (1817); Reich K., Karl Georg Christian von Staudt, Geometrie Der Lage (1847). Landmark Writings in Western Mathematics, pp. 441-447, (2005); Reye T., Geometry of Position, (1898); Sophia Foster R., Solid Geometry, (1914); Scott C.A., Introductory Modern Geometry, Bulletin of the New York Mathematical Society, 2, 7, pp. 175-178, (1893); Charlotte Angas S., An Introductory Account of Certain Modern Ideas and Methods in Plane Analytical Geometry, (1894); Charlotte Angas S., 1899. Reye’s Geometrie der Lage, Bulletin of the New York Mathematical Society, 5, 4, pp. 175-181; Scott C.A., The Status of Imaginaries in Pure Geometry, Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society, 6, 4, pp. 163-168, (1900); Charlotte Angas S., On Von Staudt’s “Geometrie der Lage, The Mathematical Gazette, 1, 19, pp. 307-314, (1900); Charlotte Angas S., On Von Staudt’s “Geometrie der Lage” (Continued), The Mathematical Gazette, 1, 20, pp. 323-331, (1900); Charlotte Angas S., On Von Staudt’s “Geometrie der Lage” (Continued), The Mathematical Gazette, 1, 22, pp. 363-370, (1900); Charlotte Angas S., On Von Staudt’s “Geometrie der Lage, The Mathematical Gazette, 1, 19, pp. 307-314, (1900); Simons L.G., A Note on Synthetic Projective Geometry, The American Mathematical Monthly, 21, 3, pp. 100-102, (1914); Smith S.E., The Department of Mathematics: History of the Department, Mount Holyoke Alumnae Quarterly, 3, 1, pp. 12-15, (1919); Marion Elizabeth S., Constructions with Limited Means the American Mathematical Monthly, 48, 7, pp. 475-479, (1941); Stark M.E., Geometrical Constructions with a Ruler, Given a Fixed Circle with Its Center, (1950); Henry Seely W., How Should the College Teach Analytic Geometry, Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society, 12, 10, pp. 493-498, (1906); Henry Seely W., Plane Curves of the Third Order, (1924); Mabel Minerva Y., Dupin’s Cyclide as a Self-Dual Surface American Journal of Mathematics, 38, 3, pp. 267-286, (1916); Mabel Minerva Y., Curves Arising from a Single Infinity of Triangles, The American Mathematical Monthly, 40, 4, pp. 196-202, (1933); (1913); (1914); (1915); (1916); (1917); (1918); (1919); (1920); (1921); (1922); Bulletin of Goucher College, Announcement of Courses For, pp. 1915-1916, (1915); Bulletin of Goucher College, Announcement of Courses For, pp. 1918-1919, (1918); Bulletin of Goucher College, Announcement of Courses For, pp. 1919-1920, (1919); Bulletin of Goucher College, Announcement of Courses For, pp. 1920-1921, (1920); Bulletin of Goucher College, Announcement of Courses For, pp. 1921-1922, (1921); Mount Holyoke College Bulletin, The Catalogue, pp. 1913-1914, (1914); Mount Holyoke College Bulletin, The Catalogue, pp. 1914-1915, (1915); Mount Holyoke College Bulletin, The Catalogue, pp. 1915-1916, (1916); Mount Holyoke College Bulletin, The Catalogue, pp. 1916-1917, (1917); Mount Holyoke College Bulletin, The Catalogue, pp. 1917-1918, (1918); Mount Holyoke College Bulletin, The Catalogue, pp. 1918-1919, (1919); Mount Holyoke College Bulletin, The Catalogue, pp. 1919-1920, (1920); Mount Holyoke College Bulletin, The Catalogue, pp. 1920-1921, (1921); Mount Holyoke College Bulletin, The Catalogue, pp. 1921-1922, (1922); Mount Holyoke College Bulletin, The Catalogue, pp. 1922-1923, (1923); Catalogue and Course of Study of the Normal College of the City of New York, (1913); Bulletin of Smith College Catalogue 1913–1914, (1913); Bulletin of Smith College Catalogue 1914–1915, (1914); Bulletin of Smith College Catalogue 1915–1916, (1915); Bulletin of Smith College Catalogue 1916–1917, (1916); Bulletin of Smith College Catalogue 1917–1918, (1917); Bulletin of Smith College Catalogue 1918–1919, (1918); Bulletin of Smith College Catalogue 1919–1920, (1919); Bulletin of Smith College Catalogue 1920–1921, (1920); Bulletin of Smith College Catalogue 1921–1922, (1921); Bulletin of Smith College Catalogue 1922–1923, (1922); Wellesley College Bulletin Calendar 1913–1914, (1914); Wellesley College Bulletin Calendar 1914–1915, (1915); Wellesley College Bulletin Calendar 1915–1916, (1916); Wellesley College Bulletin Calendar 1916–1917, (1917); Wellesley College Bulletin Calendar 1917–1918, (1918); Wellesley College Bulletin Calendar 1918–1919, (1919); Wellesley College Bulletin Calendar 1919–1920, (1920); Wellesley College Bulletin Calendar 1920–1921, (1921); Wellesley College Bulletin Calendar 1921–1922, (1922); Wellesley College Bulletin Calendar 1922–1923, (1923); Vassar College Bulletin 49Th Annual Catalogue 1913–1914, (1913); Vassar College Bulletin 50Th Annual Catalogue 1914–1915, (1914); Vassar College Bulletin 51St Annual Catalogue 1915–1916, (1915); Vassar College Bulletin 52Nd Annual Catalogue 1916–1917, (1916); Vassar College Bulletin 53Rd Annual Catalogue 1917–1918, (1917); Vassar College Bulletin 54Th Annual Catalogue 1918–1919, (1918); Vassar College Bulletin 55Th Annual Catalogue 1919–1920, (1919); Vassar College Bulletin 56Th Annual Catalogue 1920–1921, (1920); Vassar College Bulletin 57Th Annual Catalogue 1921–1922, (1921); Vassar College Bulletin 58Th Annual Catalogue 1922–1923, (1922)
Springer
Book chapter
Scopus